• Home
  • Taking a Tour
  • Amish Meals
  • FAQ About the Amish
  • Ten Reasons
  • Ten Objections
  • Contact Us
  • More
    • Home
    • Taking a Tour
    • Amish Meals
    • FAQ About the Amish
    • Ten Reasons
    • Ten Objections
    • Contact Us
  • Home
  • Taking a Tour
  • Amish Meals
  • FAQ About the Amish
  • Ten Reasons
  • Ten Objections
  • Contact Us

Ten Common Objections to Taking a Guided Tour

"I already know plenty about the Amish."

"I can walk around Shipshewana on my own."

"I can walk around Shipshewana on my own."

 If you got your information from the internet, most of it is probably either outdated, misleading, or flat out wrong!  Books get outdated too, or overgeneralize - and most are about the Lancaster County Amish, not the northern Indiana Amish.

"I can walk around Shipshewana on my own."

"I can walk around Shipshewana on my own."

"I can walk around Shipshewana on my own."

Very true. Our guided tours don't  typically make stops in the downtown area - you don't need a guide for that.  But we have a list of the "best of the best" of the tourist district - yours as a part of our tour - so tour with us first if you can.

"Private guided tours are expensive."

"I can walk around Shipshewana on my own."

"Private guided tours are expensive."

Actually, using your vehicle, your family or group can have three hours with a professional guide for about $130. Three hours of a local expert's undivided time!   

"It's not a buggy ride."

"I can read a book, and that's the same as a tour."

"Private guided tours are expensive."

Also true. A buggy ride is typically a few miles around the downtown area, and a lot of fun, but it's not the same as one of our tours. Why not do both?  (By the way, those triple-door tour buggies aren't authentic Amish buggies.)  

"There's nothing to see except cows and corn."

"I can read a book, and that's the same as a tour."

"I can read a book, and that's the same as a tour."

Actually, there's plenty to see, especially if you have a guide to explain what you're seeing - and we can show you things you can't see on your own or might not have known about.  

"I can read a book, and that's the same as a tour."

"I can read a book, and that's the same as a tour."

"I can read a book, and that's the same as a tour."

I've read books about the Apollo moon landings, but I doubt it's the same as being there.  Reading a book  is a great start (especially if it's one of my books!) - but it's not the same as experiencing another culture.

"Canned presentations are boring."

"How will the guide know what I'm interested in?"

"I don't think I'm the guided tour type."

We agree! That's why our tours are not done that way.  A customized, private guided tour like ours is all about one of us answering your questions about the Amish and talking about what you're interested in and taking you where you want to go.

"I don't think I'm the guided tour type."

"How will the guide know what I'm interested in?"

"I don't think I'm the guided tour type."

What if you really enjoy it, though?  We've had more than one husband coerced into a tour by his wife, who ended up quite enthusiastic by the end.  

"How will the guide know what I'm interested in?"

"How will the guide know what I'm interested in?"

"Isn't a guided tour the same as visiting Menno Hof?"

Simple: we ask you - before the tour, and during the tour.  And the Q&A times between stops are one of our favorite things about doing guided tours and a great way to personalize each tour.

"Isn't a guided tour the same as visiting Menno Hof?"

"Isn't a guided tour the same as visiting Menno Hof?"

"Isn't a guided tour the same as visiting Menno Hof?"

Not at all.  Menno Hof is a history museum - all about the roots of the Anabaptist movement in Europe starting in 1525, and how that movement evolved into the Amish and Mennonite churches of today.  A private tour is about the Amish as they live here and now.

Ten Reasons to Take a Guided TourTaking a TourFAQ About the Northern Indiana AmishBack to Home Page

Copyright © 2026 My Amish Indiana - All Rights Reserved.


Powered by

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept