• Home
  • Taking a Tour
  • Amish Meals
  • FAQ About the Amish
  • Ten Reasons
  • Ten Objections
  • Contact Us
  • More
    • Home
    • Taking a Tour
    • Amish Meals
    • FAQ About the Amish
    • Ten Reasons
    • Ten Objections
    • Contact Us
  • Home
  • Taking a Tour
  • Amish Meals
  • FAQ About the Amish
  • Ten Reasons
  • Ten Objections
  • Contact Us

Have a Meal in an Amish Home

Share a meal with Leah

Want to experience a meal on an Amish farm, in an Amish home?  

Leah Bontrager of Shipshewana, Indiana can take groups of 2 to 12.

About Leah

Leah and her husband Elson live on a six-acre Amish farm north of Shipshewana, Indiana.  They moved into this English-built home in January 2024 and are in the process of converting it to Amish specifications.  Leah likes bicycling, cardmaking, gardening, and travel.

How to book a meal

Contact Leah by voicemail at (574) 825-1212 and she will return your call.

(Sunday voicemails will be answered on Monday.)

48-hour notice preferred when possible.

Groups of 2 to 12 are welcome.

Special note:  No meals are offered on Sundays.


Details...

Supper: 5:30-6:45 p.m.

MENU #1:

Homemade bread with butter and Amish peanut butter

Choice of chicken or beef main course

Mashed potatoes and gravy

Noodle dish

Vegetable dish

Choice of 2 pies for dessert

Water and coffee

1-3 people:  $40 per person 

4 or more people:  $30 per person

Discount for children under 12

50% deposit required for groups of five or more.

Supper: 5:30-6:45 p.m.

MENU #2:

Soup

Salad

Sandwich

Choice of 2 pies for dessert

Water and coffee

1-3 people:  $30 per person

4 or more people:  $25 per person

Discount for children under 12

50% deposit required for groups of five or more.

Comments from Leah's Guest Book

"Thank you for a delicious meal.  Everything was wonderful.  Thanks for sharing your home and may God bless you and your family."

Kathy

"Thank you so much for the delicious food and wonderful conversation!  Thank you for making us feel so welcome in your home."

Eva & Wyatt

"This has been a most delicious meal and delightful atmosphere.  Leah is so kind and friendly - I love your smile!  Really enjoyed being here this evening."

Nancy

"Thank you so much for the delicious meal.  Enjoyed the Christian fellowship."

Sandy

"We have twin anniversary dates today - 

you 17 years, us 64 years!  God bless you.  Thank you for a lovely meal and visit!"

Julia & Walter

"Loved the time we were able to spend with you in your home.  The food was amazing and I enjoyed it so much!"

Sherry

"We have learned so much from you today about the Amish.  The meal was great and delicious.  We want to come back to meet 

your 'busy' husband, too!"

Karen & Mike

"Thank you for making us feel so welcome and for the delicious food and great conversation."

Kathy, Karen, Maryke, Kaye, & Lorraine

Brisbane, Queensland, Australia

"We had such an amazing dinner.  Our girls loved your dog Sophie so much!  All of the food was so delicious but the company was even better.  Thank you guys so much and let's keep in touch!

Mike and Julie

"Thank you for a delicious meal and wonderful fellowship.  God bless you both."

Jim and Judy, return visitors

" We cannot thank you enough for having us to dinner in your home.  Your hospitality has been exceptional.  You have been so kind to us and our kids.  Your generosity has been the highlight of our vacation.  You have made new friends in us."

Kelly and Brad

"What a wonderful experience dining with you!  The food was fantastic as well as the conversation.  We learned so much!  If you're ever near Toledo, our home is always open."

Scott and Brenda

1/10

Taking a TourBack to Home Page

Copyright © 2026 My Amish Indiana - All Rights Reserved.


Powered by

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept